Compare and purchase the best
car insurance rates
in Orillia.
Types of coverage we provide
Allows one 'free' at-fault accident, meaning your rates will not increase on your first accident if you remain with the same provider.
Windows are included in comprehensive* however; you have the option to remove this coverage to lower your premium. (*Not Included in Alberta.)
You can extend your car insurance coverage to protect you while driving a rental vehicle, up to a certain limit.
Save up to 25% by bundling your home and auto insurance
Our Reviews
Bundle Your Home & Auto To Save up to 25%!
Orillia is about a 90-minute drive north from Toronto and is considered the gateway to cottage country. Orillia sits perched over Lake Simcoe (located between Barrie and Gravenhurst) and is strategically situated at the junction of Highway 12 east-west bound and Highway 11 north-south bound. Driving in Orillia may be a little different as it is known as a retirement community so is a little quieter than other cities. Orillia also encourages “active transportation”, so you may encounter less traffic congestion during the warmer months with people using other modes of transportation (walking, skateboarding, cycling, jogging, rollerblading etc…). How fun!
When you own a car, getting auto insurance is mandatory by law across Canada. Whether you're commuting to work every day, or just using your vehicle to run weekly errands, you need car insurance. It protects you (the driver), your passengers, and pedestrians in the event of an accident. So, before you get behind the wheel talk to your Surex Advisor who can help you get on the road today!
Car Insurance in Orillia
Car insurance policies are offered by personal lines insurance providers across Canada. Contact an insurance broker so they can provide you with a quote from leading insurance providers so you can compare prices and coverage!
The average cost of car insurance in Orillia is $1,764 per year.
But, there are multiple factors that affect car insurance rates in Orillia. To get the best possible insurance rates, we recommend contacting a licensed insurance advisor to shop the market for you to get the best deals on car insurance.
Yes, all Ontario drivers including drivers in Orillia are required by the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) to have a minimum of $200,000 worth of third-party liability coverage, statutory accident benefits coverage, uninsured automobile coverage, and direct compensation & property damage coverage (DCPD).
Compare 10+ Quotes +
Speak to a Dedicated Advisor
Licensed Insurance Advisor

The best road-trip destinations in Orillia
Hit the road with confidence knowing you’re covered with the right car insurance for your needs at
the lowest possible rate. Here are some of the top spots in Orillia to explore on your next road trip.
Surex insurance tips & advice
Trump's tariffs on Canada, Mexico, and China impact industries like insurance by raising costs on goods. Retaliatory tariffs and economic tensions continue as the U.S. cites immigration and drug concerns.
Before moving out, know your legal notice obligations. This guide covers Ontario’s rules, tenant responsibilities, and tips for a hassle-free rental move.
Travel can affect your home insurance, so understand policy requirements and risks before leaving—protection goes beyond locked doors and lights while you're away.